


作为教育领域的SCIE期刊编辑,今天想和大家聊聊干预研究中最容易“踩雷”的地方,帮助大家在未来避开这些坑。
在什么情况下,教育类的干预研究会被SSCI/SCIE期刊拒稿?
干预研究(Intervention Study),或称为实验设计(Experimental Design),在编辑眼中本应是一种有深度的研究范式。与问卷调查(Survey Design)不同,实验设计能够有效验证哪些因素真正导致学生成绩或表现的差异。
然而,干预方案的开发有其严谨的规范,并非研究者可以随意设计,也不能仅凭“专家开发”就自我证明其有效性。
以下是一段拒稿信段落,你看懂背后的原因了吗?
The manuscript reports an intervention study involving students; however, several major concerns need to be addressed. First, the study does not describe any instructional design process underlying the intervention. It remains unclear how the intervention was developed. As educational interventions should be constructed and validated through systematic processes—commonly referred to as instructional design (ID)—this represents a significant methodological gap. Second, no theoretical framework, such as a learning theory, is provided to justify the intervention’s foundational principles. Which specific learning theory informs the treatments applied to the students? Clarifying this is essential for establishing the conceptual basis of the study.
#教学设计 #理论框架 #论文写作 #拒稿原因 #论文发表 #论文投稿 #干预研究 #实验设计
在什么情况下,教育类的干预研究会被SSCI/SCIE期刊拒稿?
干预研究(Intervention Study),或称为实验设计(Experimental Design),在编辑眼中本应是一种有深度的研究范式。与问卷调查(Survey Design)不同,实验设计能够有效验证哪些因素真正导致学生成绩或表现的差异。
然而,干预方案的开发有其严谨的规范,并非研究者可以随意设计,也不能仅凭“专家开发”就自我证明其有效性。
以下是一段拒稿信段落,你看懂背后的原因了吗?
The manuscript reports an intervention study involving students; however, several major concerns need to be addressed. First, the study does not describe any instructional design process underlying the intervention. It remains unclear how the intervention was developed. As educational interventions should be constructed and validated through systematic processes—commonly referred to as instructional design (ID)—this represents a significant methodological gap. Second, no theoretical framework, such as a learning theory, is provided to justify the intervention’s foundational principles. Which specific learning theory informs the treatments applied to the students? Clarifying this is essential for establishing the conceptual basis of the study.
#教学设计 #理论框架 #论文写作 #拒稿原因 #论文发表 #论文投稿 #干预研究 #实验设计


